Letting the Cat out of the Bothy Bag

Posted by on Nov 10, 2009 in Bothy | 8 Comments

I discovered recently that the Mountain Bothies Association (MBA) has caved in and published a clickable bothy map on their website. Now this information was never secret, but it was previously freely available only to members. A few years back I joined the MBA, obtained the list of bothies and annotated my OS maps with their locations. What I didn’t realise then is that  the MBA list reveals only the tip of the bothy iceberg.

To find out about the privately maintained bothies of which the submerged portion is comprised, aspiring bothiers must serve their apprenticeships. They will slowly discover the true extent of the bothy network through information hoovered from entries in bothy books or drip fed to them by bearded pensioners round the bothy hearth. There cannot be many people who know the location of all the privately maintained open bothies and I would wager that most of those who do would be wary of committing their list to writing. Visiting all the bothies in Scotland is a more appealing challenge to me than that of compleating the Munros.

A night round the fire in the reputedly haunted Ben Alder Cottage. If cycling in from the south beware the half-dozen locked gates!

A few weekends back I visited one of these ‘hidden’ bothies. I resisted spilling the beans on my blog, precisely because the place is little known. There are very few references to its existence on the internet and so the chance of passing a quiet night there are high. If I and others were to start dripping this information onto the internet it might be possible for some unprincipled scoundrel to collate it all into a dossier. The publication of such a dossier would remove forever the aura of subversiveness and mystery which is such an attractive aspect of the bothy scene.

This attitude of mine courts accusations of elitism and has a parallel in the moratorium imposed by the Scottish Mountaineering Club (SMC) on the recording of new climbing routes in the Northwest in the 1970s. The stated purpose of the moratorium was to preserve the spirit of exploration for future generations, a strategy that seemed ludicrous to many at the time. The area is now covered by a three volume set of guidebooks, each one bulging with quality routes, yet the remoteness of the Northwest means that even the most popular areas are rarely crowded. Comparing my present attitude to the position formerly held by the SMC makes me feel a shade hypocritical.

A contender for the most remote bothy in Scotland, Maol Bhuidhe. This building  boasts a rich social history – Iain R Thomson mentions it in both Isolation Shepherd and The Long Horizon. I will recount his anecdotes of the place (and my own) in a future post.

A further chink in the armour of my consistency is revealed by my enjoyment of Dave Brown and Ian Mitchell’s book ‘Mountain Days and Bothy Nights’. This is the only book I have read which accurately captures the spirit of the bothy scene. Reading about others’ experiences made my own more tangible. The book captured the period where a lack of cars led to the sociable outdoor lifestyle of ‘weekending’. I don’t know if bothying is on the way up or the way down – is the bothying life that I know, that of twos and threes, a shadow of its heyday? Might the publication of the MBA bothy locations kick start a renaissance of bothying? If it did, I’m not sure that it would be to my liking – see this previous report of an excessively busy bothy weekend.

Probably my fears are unfounded. ‘Mountain Days and Bothy Nights’ even devoted a chapter to that most prized of hill dwellings, the Secret Howff of Beinn a’Bhuird. The reputation of the howff is such that I knew of its existence long before I knew even of its approximate location. Were it not for a friend who lived for some years in Aberdeen I may never have had the pleasure of passing a night in its cosy confines. In the course of his exile he was indoctrinated into the secret ways of the Aberdonians and learned of the location of the Secret Howff. One night in the Garbh Coire Refuge, high in the Cairngorms, I begged him to reveal its location but he refused. Tradition forbade him from supplying a grid reference, but permitted him to guide me to it at a future date. The Secret Howff has not been ruined by the publicity lavished upon it in Mitchell and Brown’s book, but it is a special case; it blends into its surroundings; there is no telltale square on the map to give the game away. There are even a number of decoy howffs in the surrounding area to put aspiring howff dwellers off the scent.

The charming but often busy Sourlies bothy at the head of Loch Nevis 

This post has revealed a fundamental contradiction in my attitude to the outdoors. On the one hand I believe that the world would be a better place if more people appreciated our wild places. To this end I am in favour of promoting the outdoors and increasing participation. On the other hand I prize the solitude that is still so readily available in the Scottish hills in general, and in its lesser known bothies and howffs in particular. For now I will desist from publishing the specific locations of lesser-known bothies. Perhaps this is overly cautious; this blog hasn’t yet the circulation required to inundate many bothies simultaneously.

I’d be very interested to hear your views on the subject so please do leave comments below.



  1. Chris
    November 10, 2009

    I think that paradox / contradiction is common – i think it is great for people to enjoy the hills……but I don’t want them to be where I am.

    Great post and great blog by the way

  2. Erik
    November 10, 2009

    Share your info with others at your own and others peril 😉

  3. Alistair
    November 11, 2009

    Let sleeping cats lie…

  4. Robert Craig
    November 11, 2009

    All outdoor publicisers have to wrestle with the conundrum that the more popular their work, the busier the hills / rivers / outdoors are going to be. Wainwright for example couldn’t stand other people, so it must have been a source of sadness for him that his guides were so popular.

    Bothies work if they are rarely visited and semi-secret, or if they are well known and regulated. Right now the MBA is in that dangerous middle ground where it seems almost everyone knows of bothies, but there is no regulation of them, thus increasing the chances of bothies being crowded out, full of unpleasant or anti-social types, or vandalised.

    I’ve got a map of Scotland covered in bothies visited and yet to visit: it’s one of my most prized hillwalking posessions. Wonder if your secret one is on it?

  5. Gavin Macfie
    November 11, 2009

    Does anyone know what provoked the MBA to publish their list? The only reason I joined was to get the list so they will deprive themselves of a fair bit of income.

    We must be vigilant regarding those bothies whose heads remain below the parapet. Today the blog got a hit from a google search on the term 'beinn a' bhuird howff location'.

    I hope the search was

  6. Anonymous
    November 26, 2009

    Nice blog…but tell them bugger all!

    City dwellers can stay away!

    Craig fae Glesga ?!

  7. Anonymous
    November 28, 2010

    The mba has charity status and therefore cannot keep locations secret

  8. Kasman
    September 29, 2013

    I found the ‘secret bothy’ (Slugain) just last week after a not-to-long search and I was surprised at how well it blended in with its surroundings. Ps: Mum’s the word!


Leave a Reply